Although time consuming to make, this image may have missed the mark due to its complexity and being grossly literal. Literal because peanut butter is not that sexy. If I were to make another iteration of this image I would try two layers of peanut butter and two layers of jelly as opposed to three of each. The edges of the middle layer of peanut butter make this look unnatural. The header font could be improved with another iteration as well. Wheat bread or a baguette with a crust could be considered for yet another iteration.